Environmental and Sustainability Education (ESE) research contain empirical knowledge as well as values and norms. This article discusses how value-premises should be handled in ESE research. The article uses a theoretical model on value-premises: value-premises can be (1) explicitly stated and justified, (2) explicitly stated but not justified, or (3) implicitly embedded without critical discussion, perceived as self-evident and uncontroversial. The article argues that value-premises should be explicitly stated and justified. The implications are several. Firstly, it becomes clear which value-premises that have been chosen by the researcher and on what grounds. Secondly, it contributes to the understanding of when researchers are doing science and when they are doing politics. Thirdly, it clarifies how the value-premises are conceptualized. Fourthly, it fosters a discussion about which value-premises are accepted within the research community. Lastly, it enhances the possibility of scrutinizing the quality of the empirical research. © 2026 The Author(s). Published with license by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.